Home runLeftLogo intvTitle runRightLogo

Below is a list of ratings I've come across for various games by DougM, VGR and by going through my collection of old Electronic Gaming Monthly magazines.

Key:
DougM and VGR ratings are 1-5 (5 being best)
EGM ratings are 1-10 (10 being best)


Activision
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
ActivisionBeamriderM-005-04  
ActivisionDreadnaught FactorM-004-04  
ActivisionHappy TrailsM-003-04    
ActivisionPitfall!M-002-04 
ActivisionPitfall!M-002-04 
ActivisionRiver RaidM-007-03    
ActivisionRiver RaidM-007-03    
ActivisionStampedeM-001-04   
ActivisionWorm WhomperM-006-03  

Atarisoft
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
AtarisoftCentipede70254  
AtarisoftDefender70252  
AtarisoftPac-Man70251  

CBS
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
CBSCarnival4L2159  
CBSCarnival4L2159  
CBSCarnival4L2159  
CBSDonkey Kong4L1702    
CBSDonkey Kong4L1702    
CBSDonkey Kong7625-7D    
CBSDonkey Kong Junior4L4016    
CBSDonkey Kong Junior4L4016    
CBSDonkey Kong Junior4L4017    
CBSLadybug4L2245    
CBSLadybug4L2245    
CBSLadybug4L2245    
CBSMouse Trap7629-9A    
CBSMouse Trap4L2143    
CBSMouse Trap4L2143    
CBSTurbo    
CBSTurbo    
CBSTurbo    
CBSVenture7628-1A    
CBSVenture4L2281    
CBSVenture4L2281    
CBSZaxxon4L2109    
CBSZaxxon4L2109    
CBSZaxxon4L2109    

Coleco
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
ColecoCarnival2488  
ColecoCarnival2488  
ColecoDonkey Kong2471  
ColecoDonkey Kong2471  
ColecoDonkey Kong Junior2671  
ColecoLadybug2483  
ColecoMouse Trap2479    
ColecoTurbo2473    
ColecoVenture2477  
ColecoZaxxon2487    

Imagic
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
ImagicAtlantis720006- 
ImagicAtlantis720006- 
ImagicAtlantis720006- 
ImagicAtlantis720006-1A 
ImagicAtlantis720006-2A 
ImagicDemon Attack720005- 
ImagicDemon Attack720005- 
ImagicDemon Attack720005- 
ImagicDemon Attack720005- 
ImagicDemon Attack720005-1A 
ImagicDemon Attack720005-1A 
ImagicDemon Attack720005-2A 
ImagicDracula720009-  
ImagicDracula720009-  
ImagicDracula720009-  
ImagicDracula720009-2A  
ImagicDracula720012-1A  
ImagicDragonfire720010-  
ImagicDragonfire720010-  
ImagicDragonfire720010-  
ImagicDragonfire720010-1A  
ImagicDragonfire720010-2A  
ImagicFathom720026-  
ImagicFathom720026-  
ImagicFathom720026-  
ImagicFathom720026-1A  
ImagicFathom720026-2A  
ImagicIce Trek720012-  
ImagicIce Trek720012-  
ImagicIce Trek720012-  
ImagicIce Trek720012-1A  
ImagicIce Trek720012-2A  
ImagicMicrosurgeon720013- 
ImagicMicrosurgeon720013- 
ImagicMicrosurgeon720013- 
ImagicMicrosurgeon720013- 
ImagicMicrosurgeon720013-1A 
ImagicNova Blast720022-  
ImagicNova Blast720022-  
ImagicNova Blast720022-  
ImagicNova Blast720022-1A  
ImagicNova Blast720022-2A  
ImagicSafecracker720025-  
ImagicSafecracker720025-  
ImagicSafecracker720025-  
ImagicSafecracker720025-1A  
ImagicSafecracker720025-2A  
ImagicSwords & Serpents720009- 
ImagicSwords & Serpents720009- 
ImagicSwords & Serpents720009-1A 
ImagicSwords & Serpents720009-2A 
ImagicSwords & Serpents720009-2A 
ImagicTropical Trouble720017-  
ImagicTropical Trouble720017-  
ImagicTropical Trouble720017-  
ImagicTropical Trouble720017-1A  
ImagicTropical Trouble720017-2A  
ImagicTruckin'720023-  
ImagicTruckin'720023-  
ImagicTruckin'720023-  
ImagicTruckin'720023-1A  
ImagicTruckin'720023-2A  
ImagicTruckin'720023-  
ImagicWhite Water!720024-  
ImagicWhite Water!720024-  
ImagicWhite Water!720024-  
ImagicWhite Water!720024-1A  
ImagicWhite Water!720024-2A  

Interphase
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
InterphaseBlockade Runner8010001    
InterphaseBlockade Runner8010001    
InterphaseSewer Sam8010002  
InterphaseSewer Sam8010002  

Intv
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
IntvBody Slam Super Pro Wrestling9009    
IntvChampionship Tennis8200  
IntvChip Shot Super Pro Golf8900    
IntvCommando9000    
IntvDig Dug9005  
IntvDiner8800  
IntvHover Force8500  
IntvMountain Madness Super Pro Skiing9007    
IntvPac-Man8000  
IntvPac-Man8000  
IntvPole Position9004    
IntvPole Position9004    
IntvSlam Dunk Super Pro Basketball9001    
IntvSlap Shot Super Pro Hockey9003    
IntvSpiker Super Pro Volleyball9102    
IntvStadium Mud Buggies9100    
IntvSuper Pro Decathlon9008    
IntvSuper Pro Football8400    
IntvThin Ice8300  
IntvThunder Castle4469  
IntvThunder Castle4469  
IntvTower of Doom8600  
IntvTriple Challenge8700    
IntvWorld Cup Soccer8100    

Mattel
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
MattelAdvanced Dungeons & Dragons3410 
MattelAdvanced Dungeons & Dragons3410 
MattelAdvanced Dungeons & Dragons Treasure of Tarmin5300  
MattelAdvanced Dungeons & Dragons Treasure of Tarmin5300  
MattelArmor Battle1121 
MattelArmor Battle1121 
MattelArmor Battle1121 
MattelArmor Battle1121 
MattelArmor Battle1121 
MattelAstrosmash!3605   
MattelAstrosmash!3605   
MattelAstrosmash!3605   
MattelAuto Racing1113   
MattelAuto Racing1113   
MattelAuto Racing1113   
MattelB-17 Bomber3884 
MattelBackgammon1119   
MattelBackgammon1119   
MattelBackgammon1119   
MattelBaseball2614   
MattelBaseball2614   
MattelBaseball2614   
MattelBasketball2615   
MattelBasketball2615   
MattelBomb Squad3883 
MattelBowling3333   
MattelBowling3333   
MattelBoxing1819   
MattelBoxing1819   
MattelBump n Jump4688  
MattelBump n Jump4688  
MattelBump n Jump4688  
MattelBurgertime4549  
MattelBurgertime4549  
MattelBurgertime  
MattelBuzz Bombers4436  
MattelBuzz Bombers4436  
MattelCheckers1120   
MattelCheckers1120   
MattelChess3412   
MattelChess3412   
MattelChess3412   
MattelDemonstration Cartridge5853-0210    
MattelDemonstration Cartridge1682-0950    
MattelDemonstration Cartridge1682-0950    
MattelDraughts1120   
MattelFootball2610   
MattelFootball2610   
MattelFootball2610   
MattelFrog Bog5301 
MattelFrog Bog5301 
MattelGolf1816   
MattelGolf1816   
MattelGolf1816   
MattelHockey1114   
MattelHockey1114   
MattelHorse Racing1123   
MattelHorse Racing1123   
MattelInternational DemoNONE    
MattelKool-Aid Man4675  
MattelKool-Aid Man4675  
MattelLearning Fun I9002    
MattelLearning Fun II9006    
MattelLock n Chase5637 
MattelLock n Chase5637 
MattelLock n Chase5637 
MattelLoco-Motion4438  
MattelLoco-Motion4438  
MattelMELODY     
MattelMasters of the Universe: The Power of He-Man4689  
MattelMasters of the Universe: The Power of He-Man4689  
MattelMasters of the Universe: The Power of He-Man4689  
MattelMath Fun2613   
MattelMath Fun2613   
MattelMelody Blaster4540    
MattelMelody Blaster4540    
MattelMelody Blaster4540    
MattelMind Strike4531    
MattelMind Strike4531    
MattelMission X4437  
MattelMission X4437  
MattelMotocross3411  
MattelMotocross3411  
MattelMr Basic Meets Bits & Bytes4536   
MattelMr Basic Meets Bits & Bytes4536   
MattelNight Stalker5305 
MattelNight Stalker5305 
MattelPinball5356  
MattelPinball5356  
MattelPoker & Blackjack2611    
MattelREV DEMO     
MattelReversi5304   
MattelReversi5304   
MattelRoulette1118   
MattelRoyal Dealer5303   
MattelRoyal Dealer5303   
MattelScooby Doo's Maze Chase4533  
MattelScooby Doo's Maze Chase4533  
MattelSea Battle1818   
MattelSea Battle1818   
MattelShark! Shark!5387  
MattelShark! Shark!5387  
MattelSharp Shot5638    
MattelSharp Shot5638    
MattelSkiing1817   
MattelSkiing1817   
MattelSkiing1817   
MattelSkiing1817   
MattelSnafu3758 
MattelSnafu3758 
MattelSnafu3758 
MattelSoccer1683   
MattelSoccer1683   
MattelSoccer1683   
MattelSpace Armada3759 
MattelSpace Armada3759 
MattelSpace Armada3759 
MattelSpace Battle2612 
MattelSpace Battle2612 
MattelSpace Hawk5136 
MattelSpace Hawk5136 
MattelSpace Spartans3416 
MattelStar Strike5161 
MattelStar Strike5161 
MattelStar Strike5161 
MattelSub Hunt3408   
MattelSub Hunt3408   
MattelT-Card     
MattelT-Card     
MattelT-Card     
MattelT-Card     
MattelTRON Deadly Discs5391 
MattelTRON Deadly Discs5391 
MattelTRON Maze-a-tron5392 
MattelTRON Maze-a-tron5392 
MattelTRON Solar Sailer5393 
MattelTennis1814   
MattelTennis1814   
MattelTennis1814   
MattelTennis1814   
MattelTest CartridgeNONE    
MattelTest CartridgeNONE    
MattelTest CartridgeNONE    
MattelTest CartridgeNONE    
MattelTest CartridgeNONE    
MattelTest CartridgeNONE    
MattelThe Jetsons Ways With Words4543  
MattelThe Jetsons Ways With Words4543  
MattelTriple Action3760 
MattelTriple Action3760 
MattelTriple Action3760 
MattelUtopia5149 
MattelUtopia5149 
MattelVectron5788  
MattelVectron5788  
MattelWord Fun1122   
MattelWord Fun1122   
MattelWorld Championship Baseball5789    
MattelWorld Series Major League Baseball4537  
MattelWorld Series Major League Baseball4537  
MattelYogi's Frustration     

Parker Brothers
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
Parker BrothersFrogger6300 
Parker BrothersPopeye6370    
Parker BrothersPopeye    
Parker BrothersQ*Bert6360  
Parker BrothersStar Wars: The Empire Strikes Back6050 
Parker BrothersSuper Cobra6320    
Parker BrothersSuper Cobra6320    
Parker BrothersTutankham6340    

Sears
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
SearsArmor Battle49-75211 
SearsAstrosmash!49-75229   
SearsAuto Racing49-75205   
SearsBackgammon49-75214   
SearsBaseball49-75202   
SearsBasketball49-75203   
SearsBowling49-75223   
SearsBoxing49-75221   
SearsCheckers49-75215   
SearsFootball49-75201   
SearsFrog Bog49-75234 
SearsGolf49-75207   
SearsHockey49-75204   
SearsHorse Racing49-75209   
SearsNight Stalker49-75236 
SearsPoker & Blackjack49-75222    
SearsRoulette49-75208   
SearsSea Battle49-75213   
SearsSkiing49-75219   
SearsSoccer49-75212   
SearsSpace Armada49-75226 
SearsSpace Battle49-75212 
SearsSpace Hawk49-75333 
SearsStar Strike49-75231 
SearsSub Hunt49-75225   
SearsTennis49-75218   
SearsTriple Action49-75230 
SearsUtopia49-75232 

Sega
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
SegaCongo Bongo006-06  

Sylvania
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability

Tandy
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability

World Book
Maker Title Model Number DougM EGM VGR Graphics VGR Playability
World BookWorld Book Tutor-Vision